• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Andy Dehnart

writer, TV critic, teacher

  • about me
  • writing
    • highlights
    • essays and reviews
    • long-form journalism
    • reporting and journalism
    • publications
  • speaking
    • What I can do for you
    • interviews and press
  • newsletter
  • contact me

msnbc.com

Andy Dehnart > writing > publications > msnbc.com

Starting in 2004, I contributed to the entertainment coverage at msnbc.com, later known as NBC News,then the most-popular news web site. I primarily wrote about television, and served as the interim TV editor for a period of time.

Television criticism and features

  • 25 seasons on, ‘Real World’ as immature as ever / 3.9.11
  • ‘Bachelor’ Brad is back — but will fans watch? / 1.17.11
  • On reality TV, quitting can be a winning strategy / 12.3.10
  • ‘Survivor’ finally brings the crazy with its cast / 10.5.10
  • New twists on ‘Survivor’ could impact the game / 9.14.10
  • Reality gets a few twists this fall / 9.2.10
  • How will ‘Idol’ fare against Cowell’s ‘X Factor’? / 1.11.10
  • For ‘Big Bang’s’ Sheldon, the nerd is the word / 11.2.09
  • Fall comedies preview: Accidentally on Purpose, Community, Modern Family, Cougar Town, Brothers, Eastwick, Glee, The Middle, The Cleveland Show / 9.21.09
  • ‘Survivor’ villain promises to destroy own food / 9.14.09
  • Reality show standbys return for fall / 9.11.09
  • Reality TV scandals aren’t just on the screen / 9.2.09
  • ‘Mad Men’ characters soften difficult themes / 8.12.09
  • Abdul’s exit could rejuvenate or kill ‘Idol’ / 8.5.09
  • Food shows keep on dishing up competitions / 7.29.09
  • ‘Bachelor’ shows love their lack of romance / 7.12.09
  • Big Brother hopes viewers click with cliques / 7.7.09
  • Summertime, and the TV watching is easy / 7.5.09
  • Five top TV shows on the bubble / 5.18.09
  • Five top ways ‘Idol’ pimps its favorite contestants / 5.11.09
  • First impressions count on new ‘Survivor’ / 2.5.09
  • New judge has already improved ‘Idol’ / 1.20.09
  • Marathons only improve ‘A Christmas Story’ / 12.21.08
  • Reality TV presents plenty of moral dilemmas / 12.15.08
  • ‘Idol’ to make changes in 2009 / 12.12.08
  • ‘Mentalist’ follows CBS formula, with a twist / 11.20.08
  • ‘CSI: Miami’ is watchable, yet horrible / 11.9.08
  • ‘Pushing Daisies’ has to struggle back to life / 10.16.08
  • At last! The secrets of ‘Survivor’ answered / 10.12.08
  • ‘Survivor’ will shine spotlight on pristine Gabon / 9.22.08
  • Show that celebrates TV is itself a crashing bore / 9.22.08
  • ‘Survivor: Gabon’ throws temptations at cast / 9.22.08
  • Emmys get a reality check—at last / 9.18.08
  • Not much new in reality-show genre / 9.4.08
  • Fall 2008 preview: Fox’s Fringe, NBC’s Crusoe, and NBC’s Kath & Kim / 9.4.08
  • ‘Project Runway’ needs a fresh design / 8.26.08
  • Can ‘Mole’s’ return live up to fans’ memories? / 6.5.08
  • Strike not to blame for drop in TV viewership / 5.11.08
  • After 19 seasons, ‘Real World’ hasn’t changed / 4.15.08
  • Pairing contestants with ‘soulmates’ latest drama-inducing tactic on ‘Big Brother’ / 2.12.08
  • Strike was devastating — but not to viewers / 2.10.08
  • Colbert, Stewart make do without writers / 1.16.08
  • ‘Dexter’ is poised for a graceful, conflicted finale / 12.14.07
  • Talent level rises on new season of ‘Runway’ 11.14.07
  • ‘Prison Break’ can’t escape conspiracy theory 11.13.07
  • ‘Family Guy’ is no cheap ‘Simpsons’ knockoff / 11.5.07
  • Controversial ‘Kid Nation’ is at times uncomfortable — and inspiring 9.26.07
  • ‘Survivor’ still stays fresh after seven years / 9.19.07
  • CBS should be ashamed of ‘Big Brother’ / 9.18.07
  • Lovable Tim Gunn misses target on ‘Style’ / 9.7.07
  • Fall TV preview: Big Bang Theory, Moonlight, Viva Laughlin, Cane / 9.07
  • ‘Kid Nation’ most notable of new reality shows / 8.29.07
  • Fun Paula, Diva Paula co-star on Abdul’s show / 6.28.07
  • It’s fitting that ‘Sopranos’ won’t give up answers / 6.11.07
  • ‘Grey’s’ spinoff shows familiar potential / 5.8.07
  • ‘Sopranos’ heads for exit with quiet power / 5.7.07
  • ‘Grey’s’ spinoff shows familiar potential / 5.4.07
  • Ominous future awaits Tony on ‘Sopranos’ / 4.9.07
  • ‘Addison’s Anatomy’ will only hurt ‘Grey’s’ / 3.7.06
  • ‘Top Chef’ fails the taste test / 2.1.07
  • O’Reilly vs. Colbert: More fizzle than sizzle / 1.18.07
  • L.A. ‘Apprentice’ throws in some new twists / 1.7.07
  • ‘Prison Break’ finds freedom outside of walls / 11.27.06
  • Fall 2006 preview: FOX’s Justice, FOX’s Vanished, FOX’s Standoff, and NBC’s Kidnapped / 9.1.06
  • Fall preview: Reality shows stick to the old and familiar / 9.1.06
  • Can ‘Project Runway’ maintain the magic? / 7.11.06
  • Janice Dickinson redefines model behavior / 7.7.06
  • Like Sydney, ‘Alias’ kept reinventing itself / 5.19.06
  • No shackles on ‘Prison Break’ finale / 5.15.06
  • ‘Unan1mous’ is unpredictable joy ride to hell / 4.19.06
  • ‘24’ has finally hit its stride / 4.17.06
  • At five, ‘Apprentice’ needs a reorg / 2.27.06
  • Immunity idol complicates ‘Survivor Panama’ / 2.1.06
  • Fashion reality show returns to the ‘Runway’ / 12.7.05
  • On ‘Prison Break,’ there’s no escape / 11.30.05
  • ‘Housewives’ desperately needs a makeover / 11.13.05
  • ‘Survivor’ survives by never truly changing / 9.14.05
  • Fall preview: Reality shows are tweaking old formulas / 9.1.05
  • Fall preview: CBS’ ‘Threshold’ / 9.1.05
  • Audience is clay in Aiken’s hands / 8.9.05
  • ‘Big Brother’: So awful, yet so addictive / 7.22.05
  • Modern reality TV turns five / 5.31.05
  • ‘Trek’ has drifted since ‘Next Generation’ / 5.12.05
  • Exclusive interview with “Amazing Race 6“‘s Jonathan: ‘I would never hit Victoria’ / 3.21.05
  • ‘Carnivàle’ returns — please let there be plot / 1.6.05
  • Don’t be ashamed to love ‘The OC’ / 11.1.04

 

Commentary

  • Don’t be a hater! Not all reality TV is trash / 11.2.10
  • Best reality shows you aren’t watching / 11.2.10
  • All-stars on ‘Survivor’ ultimately disappoint / 2.11.10
  • New ‘Idol’ season should learn from last year / 1.11.10
  • Paula-free ‘Idol’ should make more changes / 1.11.10
  • For kids’ sake, ‘Jon & Kate’ needs to stop now / 10.6.09
  • On ‘American Idol,’ strength can be a weakness / 5.5.09
  • Reality judges range from wise to wacko / 11.17.08
  • New judge will instantly improve ‘Idol’ / 8.26.08
  • Five reality shows that are begging for tune-ups / 7.16.08
  • 6 critical changes needed to revive ‘Big Brother’ / 4.27.08
  • Humility could doom Archuleta on ‘Idol’ / 3.7.08
  • Advantage super-fans on latest ‘Survivor’? / 2.6.08
  • ‘Idol’ talent not ‘fresh, untapped’ / 1.29.08
  • Nowhere to go but down for false ‘Idol’ / 1.10.08
  • Samantha Harris slips back into ‘Dancing’ / 10.16.07
  • ‘Big Brother’s’ competing realities / 8.24.07
  • Summer reality shows fit the laid-back season / 8.15.07
  • Win for Blake would restore ‘Idol’ as hitmaker / 5.22.07
  • Paula Abdul: Don’t call her crazy anymore / 5.14.07
  • Sanjaya could actually win ‘American Idol’ / 4.17.07
  • ‘American Idol’ has begun its decline / 3.13.07
  • ‘Idol’ judges aren’t meaner, it’s the editors / 1.30.07
  • ‘Idol’ judges have grown into their roles / 1.15.07
  • What twist is lurking for ‘American Idol’? / 1.8.07
  • ‘Apprentice’ moves west, with same old Trump / 1.4.07
  • Book review: “The Life and Times of the Thunderbolt Kid” by Bill Bryson / 10.7.06
  • Book review: “My Ox is Broken” by Adam-Troy Castro / 10.1.06
  • Why ‘Lost’ has lost me as a viewer / 10.4.06
  • Why are all-star reality shows so disappointing? / 8.21.06
  • Gloves are coming off for ‘Contender 2’ / 7.19.06
  • Lack of ‘Idol’ vote information frustrates fans / 5.23.06
  • J.J. Abrams: the Goldilocks of filmmakers / 5.7.06
  • What a long, strange ‘Idol’ season it’s been / 5.4.06
  • How could ‘Dreamz’ miss such an easy target? / 4.20.06
  • Shane is latest ‘Survivor’ viewers love to hate / 4.13.06
  • Most important ‘Idol’ judge? It’s Paula Abdul / 3.21.06
  • ‘Idol’ season four: Country vs. rock ‘n’ roll / 1.6.06
  • ‘Idol’ season three: William Hung to Fantasia / 12.30.05
  • ‘Idol’ season two: Where are they now? / 12.27.05
  • First season ‘Idols’: Where are they now? / 12.20.05
  • 10 scariest characters: ‘Prison Break’s T-Bag, ‘Family Guy’ monkey, ‘Desperate Housewives’ cast / 10.24.05
  • ‘Amazing Race’ has lost its way / 9.27.05
  • Vote Martha’s catchphrase off the island / 8.31.05
  • Rob and Amber’s success hurts ‘Amazing Race’ / 4.26.05
  • Moviegoers trapped by pre-show ads / 4.13.05
  • How has ‘Survivor’ continued to survive? / 12.3.04
  • Cruel reality shows don’t play fair / 11.5.04

Episode analysis

  • ‘Survivor Tocantins’ is down to its final four / 5.14.09
  • ‘Survivor’ crowns its newest millionaire / 5.17.09
  • ‘Bachelor’ breaks two hearts in season finale / 3.3.09
  • Hollywood round has been disaster for ‘Idol’ / 2.5.09
  • Bob the non-player outwits, outlasts ‘em all / 12.15.08
  • ‘Survivor Gabon’ winner? What about Bob? / 12.12.08
  • ‘Survivor’ gets personal as season nears end / 11.20.08
  • ‘Survivor’ delivers surprises right until the end / 5.12.08
  • Favorites have best shot at winning ‘Survivor’ / 5.7.08
  • “Survivor” student’s alliance, plans pay off / 12.17.07
  • Gizzie needs to be surgically cut from “Grey’s” / 11.7.07
  • Underdog “Survivors” betting on $1 million / 12.13.07
  • Television deserves better than weak Emmys / 9.16.07
  • The “Grey’s” we’ve known is over … so over / 5.21.07
  • Broken promises abound on “Survivor” finale / 5.14.07
  • Rocker chick sent back to nest on “Idol” / 4.4.06
  • Halfway through day, “24” needs to pick up pace / 3.6.07
  • Oscar’s best moments weren”t in the script / 2.26.07
  • “Idol” women try some risky business / 2.22.07
  • Golden Globes wins points for stars” goofiness / 1.16.07
  • “Survivor” closes book on compelling season / 12.17.06
  • Handicapping the final five “Survivor” players / 12.14.06
  • Laying odds on this season’s “Amazing Race” / 10.9.06
  • “Housewives” gets back to sudsy business / 9.24.06
  • Racial divide doesn’t change “Survivor” / 9.14.06
  • Quiet “Sopranos” finale offers no clues / 6.4.06
  • “Housewives” finale looks to the past / 5.21.06
  • Taylor a lock to make final two on “Idol” / 5.16.06
  • On “Survivor,” Aras won by outlasting / 5.14.06
  • “Survivor” final four: It’s anybody’s game / 5.11.06
  • Real, dream families blend for Tony Soprano / 3.19.06
  • “Sopranos” returns with a bang / 3.12.06
  • Fired “Apprentice” just couldn”t keep quiet / 2.27.06
  • “Idol” results show revels in cruelty / 2.24.06
  • TV favorites rewarded, if miscategorized / 1.17.06
  • ‘Apprentice’ winner refuses to share title / 12.16.05
  • ‘Survivor’ finalists were consistent to the end / 12.11.05
  • Curse of the car leads ‘Survivor’ to final four / 12.8.05
  • Survivor’s paranoia is self-fulfilling prophecy / 11.17.05
  • ‘Survivor’ keeps shaking things up / 10.20.05
  • ‘Survivor’ has new tribes, but old cliques / 10.06.05
  • Apprentices display male-pattern dumbness / 9.29.05
  • For ‘Apprentice,’ it’s just like old times / 9.22.05
  • Trump seeks an ‘Apprentice’ he won’t hate / 9.22.05
  • Rock, hard place meet the ‘Big Brother’ finale / 9.20.05
  • Emmy tries to be hip but still ends up boring / 9.19.05
  • ‘Survivor’ gets tough in Guatemala / 9.15.05
  • ‘Big Brother’ finally grows up / 8.12.05
  • Mysteries of ‘Lost’ detract from the characters / 5.25.05
  • Trump should have hired both women / 5.19.05
  • ‘Apprentice’ not a test of corporate skills / 5.18.05
  • Tom wins [‘Survivor’], but Ian will be remembered / 5.15.05
  • ‘Survivor’ finale tough to handicap / 5.12.05
  • Gut-wrenching ‘Race’ offers satisfying ending / 5.11.05
  • ‘Idol’ special offered a lot of nothing / 5.4.05
  • Quitting time on reality TV / 4.21.05
  • Which Apprentice will Trump them all? / 4.14.05
  • ‘Apprentice’ sponsors are the real losers / 4.8.05
  • The Donald, wrong? Say it isn’t so / 3.24.05
  • Beauty and the Beasts: Sexism reigns on The Apprentice 3 / 3.3.05
  • ‘Survivor returns with surprises / 2.17.05
  • ‘Apprentice’ ads don’t connect / 2.10.05
  • Auditions make ‘Idol’ a joke / 2.2.05
  • Type A Apprentices need an intervention / 1.27.05
  • ‘Apprentice 3’ candidates make it personal / 1.20.05
  • ‘Idol’ judges starting to crack up / 1.19.05
  • Welcome to another season of ‘Delusional Idol’ / 1.18.05
  • ‘Race’ contestant has somebody to shove / 12.22.04
  • Trump turns ‘Apprentice’ into ‘Idol’ / 12.16.04
  • Final Survivor was the best liar / 12.12.04
  • You’re fired! And … so are you! / 11.19.04
  • Raj was just too much like Trump / 11.5.04
  • What’s with Trump’s weird voiceovers? / 10.29.04
  • “Survivor” strategies are shifting / 10.15.04

Ask the Reality TV Experts column

  • MTV may have lost all faith in ‘Road Rules’; Excess skin on ‘Biggest Loser’; online voting for ‘American Idol’ / 6.11.08
  • Competitions rule summer reality TV; Shared lots for reality shows; condition of ‘Extreme Makeover’ homes / 5.11.08
  • ‘Dancing’ costumes cha-cha for charity / 5.4.08
  • Fate of ‘Real World’ houses varies after filming; Why doesn’t ‘Supernanny’ film in small homes?; Running ‘Hell’s Kitchen’ / 5.27.08
  • How judges avoid scoring errors on ‘Dancing’; How ‘Survivor’ contestants travel; cost of HGTV’s home upgrades / 4.20.08
  • ‘Biggest Loser’ contestants have long workouts; Where ‘Idol’ contestants live; how far $5K goes on ‘What Not to Wear’ / 4.15.08
  • ‘Idol’ hopefuls get help on song arrangements; Update on ‘Hell’s Kitchen’ contestants; origin of reality-show meals / 4.6.08
  • Readers pick ‘Dancing’s’ Bergeron as best host; When cast members are interviewed; going hungry on ‘Hell’s Kitchen’ / 3.23.08
  • Gladiators’ isn’t scripted — for the most part; Reality show winners with their own shows; ‘Survivor’s’ many exits / 3.23.08
  • Maks puts ‘Dancing’ on hold for the season; recycling reality TV stars; are reality shows ‘stupid’ and ‘cruel’? / 3.16.08
  • ‘Survivor’ host Jeff Probst isn’t omniscient; How ‘Dancing’ celebs are selected; why Hilfiger’s ‘The Cut’ is gone / 3.9.08
  • Why men go topless at ‘Biggest Loser’ weigh-ins; gay ‘Big Brother’ contestant’s departure; best reality TV host Emmy / 2.29.08
  • Having a theme is a first for ‘Idol’ semifinalists; building challenges for ‘Survivor’; getting cash for ‘Amazing Race’ / 2.17.08

Primary Sidebar

Andy Dehnart, photographed by Kellie Warren, March 2019

Hi! I'm Andy, a writer and teacher who obsessively and critically covers reality TV and unscripted entertainment, focusing on how it’s made and what it means. Learn more about me.

follow me

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

RSS recent writing on reality blurred

  • Hulu’s new show wants to make you uncomfortable, because we’ve been ‘indoctrinated’
  • Squid games leave squid juice squirting on Tough As Nails
  • Physical: 100 is a visually spectacular but bulky strength competition
  • Rachel Reilly’s answers to all of my Traitors questions
  • The Traitors US: Who won? Who was banished? Betrayed? Recaps of episodes 6-10
  • Oil and tears spill everywhere on Tough As Nails
  • 25 reality TV news and must-read stories: prison, renewals, Netflix, and more
  • How Trafficked films ‘risky and dangerous situations’—and deals with ‘holy sh*t’ moments
  • Are all Great Pottery Throw Down seasons streaming? Why do TV shows end mid-season?
  • Milf Manor’s twist was exactly what we expected

what I’ve been doing

  • Three podcasts, two stories, one wild year December 30, 2021
  • Thank you again, SPJ Florida! August 8, 2021
  • Me and my writing, in your inbox October 24, 2019
  • I asked CBS executives about their reality shows’ problems with race. Here’s what happened. August 16, 2019
  • An anniversary, and three recommendations, plus a way to really stay up to date July 15, 2019

“It’s good to be curious about many things.”

—Mister Rogers

Footer

RSS recent reality blurred stories

  • Hulu’s new show wants to make you uncomfortable, because we’ve been ‘indoctrinated’
  • Squid games leave squid juice squirting on Tough As Nails
  • Physical: 100 is a visually spectacular but bulky strength competition
  • Rachel Reilly’s answers to all of my Traitors questions
  • The Traitors US: Who won? Who was banished? Betrayed? Recaps of episodes 6-10

let’s connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Find me on Mastodon

Copyright© 2015–2023 Reality Blurred LLC. Thanks for visiting.